Quantcast willametteLive.com || Homeopathy no better than a placebo?

willamettelive.com - your source for news in the willamette valley
ADVERTISEMENT

   

Log-in | Signup (Free!)  |  Advertise  
Homeopathy no better than a placebo?
By Michelle Andujar
from WillametteLive, Section Wellness
Posted on Sun May 31, 2009 at 10:39:12 PM PDT

Aspirin is used to treat pain, fever and inflammation. Its various side effects include ringing in the ears and hemorrhages. Prepared homeopathically, aspirin can be used to treat the very same symptoms it is capable of causing.

"You'd expect a remedy made from aspirin to be helpful for Meniere's syndrome," explained Dr. Stephen Albin, Salem's only full-time homeopathic doctor.

Homeopathy means "similar to the suffering," because it's based on the principle of "like cures like." This is why many of the remedies are made of poisonous substances; however, they are diluted to a point where toxicity is impossible, as opposed to conventional and herbal medicine, which use substances in their raw forms. Therefore, it is very safe, even for pregnant and nursing women. The remedies strengthen the body's immune response, acting somewhat like a vaccine.

Homeopathic medicine can be a powerful alternative to treat a wide range of conditions, mental or physical, including virtually any viral, bacterial, or fungal infection.

"Over the years, I've used other therapies, but I've found that homeopathy is the most curative of all. I tell you, if you've worked with something for 30 years, you know it works. I would've given up on it a long time ago if it didn't," Albin, a licensed naturopath, said.

According to homeopathic theory, pathologies that are suppressed with drugs tend to manifest themselves later in different organs. Homeopathy attempts to remove the roots of disease, something referred to as "miasms," which are illnesses that have afflicted humans for hundreds of years, such as syphilis and tuberculosis, leaving a genetic disturbance and causing a range of side effects in the following generations, from asthma to cancer.

Some critics claim that homeopathy is no better than a placebo, but Dr. Albin, who recently helped a 15-year-old cat recover from paralysis, contended that homeopathy works well on babies and animals.

"The most logical conclusion is that it is not based on faith. Homeopathy, statistically, works much better than placebos."

He clarified that some studies have come to that conclusion because they come from an allopathic perspective, where one remedy is used to treat one specific disease.

In homeopathy, all mental, emotional, physical and personality symptoms are taken into account to prescribe a remedy that works well for that person. There are thousands of remedies, and the wrong remedy would have no effect on the patient.

Since the FDA began regulating homeopathic remedies, it has labeled each one for a specific problem, just as regular medicine is labeled.

"This has caused many people to take the wrong remedy. You might have to try a couple of different remedies until you find the most appropriate. It really depends on the skill of the homeopathic doctor and how well the patient can communicate his or her symptoms," Albin said. "If something doesn't work, don't assume that homeopathy doesn't work. You probably tried the wrong remedy."

Albin predicts that homeopathy will become increasingly popular as people use it and see its effectiveness: "Buy a bottle of Arnica and try it the next time you hurt yourself. Arnica is so effective to treat bruises and traumas that during World War II, every German soldier had it in his medical kit."

"I've treated people who have taken nothing but homeopathy their whole lives, and they're the healthiest people," Albin said.




Homeopathy IS INDEED Better Than Placebo (#1)
by Anonymous on Mon Jun 01, 2009 at 05:11:49 AM PDT
In a recent Journal of Clinical Epidemiology article, a 2005 meta analysis of Homeopathy trials which had appeared in Lancet and which had claimed that Homeopathy performed no better than placebo, was completely refuted. In addition the Lancet article failed to mention earlier and better meta-analyses which had also appeared in Lancet and which clearly showed Homeopathy performed well above placebo. People are often surprised to learn that out of the original 110 trials, the Lancet article actually based its sweeping conclusions on 8 (eight!!) trials. Anti Homeopathists are gradually being forced to admit the Homeopathic curative effect due to its increasing useage but then cover up that admission by again attacking it as "just placebo effect", or worse, as "just water" - completely ignoring the experiments of M. Ennis which clearly show that high dilutions of a substance, in which all molecules of the stimulant have been diluted away, are STILL able to cause biological effects as though the stimulant were still there. As Dr. Rustum Roy puts it - graphite and diamond are very different substances, one very soft the other VERY hard - but "it's just Carbon"!! Thank goodness people are starting to realize that Homeopathy's time has finally come and it will be increasingly used and researched. ScepticsBane

Great topic (#2)
by Anonymous on Mon Jun 01, 2009 at 05:37:48 AM PDT
Heomeopathy could be the best way to treat many illnesses and could stop the absurd consumption of pills, a sad and incredibly huge adiction of our society. Great article and great to read about this more and more. For those of us who've used homeopathy all our lives, and don't know what it means to use pain killers or antibiotics as a daily basis, this is a prove of our results using it. Thanks Michelle

one time patient (#3)
by Anonymous on Mon Jun 01, 2009 at 03:38:22 PM PDT
Dr Albin treated me with a single dose of a homeopathic remedy 18 years ago, well it will be 18 years ago in exactly two weeks from today. It made a world of difference to me. Enough so that I can mark my life as before and after his treatment. I can tell you what a great difference seeing Dr Albin made in my life. Sincerely, Jacob Schor, ND

Homeopathy is Absurd (#4)
by ejensen6 on Tue Jun 02, 2009 at 12:51:00 PM PDT
Homeopathic remedies are diluted to the point where not a single molecule of the orignial ingredient remains, meaning that a homeopathic remedy consists entirely of water. Apologists claim that this water has a memory of being in contact with something else, but this memory has never been demonstrated and replicated. In fact, this memory has been proven false by the following paper: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15758995 -Erik Jensen

It's not 'Just' Water (#5)
by Anonymous on Wed Jun 03, 2009 at 12:55:09 AM PDT
http://homeoinst.org/material/Newsletter/HRI%20Newsletter%20Jan%202008.pdf A very interesting research into the way in which water actually can transmit the essence of the remedy. It's amazing how something so simple can be so curative. You should try it before you rule it out, Erik, it might save your life some day. It helped save the life of Roger Daltrey's son, the lead singer of The Who. Here is the story: http://www.prlog.org/10070248-roger-daltrey-homeopathy-saved-my-son.html

Homepathic "Research" (#6)
by ejensen6 on Thu Jun 04, 2009 at 12:49:40 PM PDT
The newsletter (not research) you cite refers to a paper on measuring "water memory". The paper itself is a self-published (R. Roy is both an author and publisher of this paper) literature review. This literature review cites experiments that purport to use intent (magic) to alter the structure of water. To sum, homeopathy = magic. The celebrity testimonial only serves to illustrate the post hoc fallacy, but I will certainly take your advice and drink a glass of water. -Erik

Homepathic Research is Genuine (#7)
by Anonymous on Sat Jun 06, 2009 at 03:22:54 PM PDT
@ejensen6 would have us believe that Dr. Rustum Roy, a professor emeritus of Materials Science at a major university and the author of an internationally famous textbook on crystalline chemistry, has written about magic. The existence of bonafide researchers with impressive credentials such as Dr. Iris Bell, Dr. Roy, Dr. Louis Rey, Dr. Sainte-Laude, Dr. Belon and others, is apparently lost on these "Homeopathy is placebo", and "homeopathy is nonsense" pseudo science armchair skeptics who apparently do not have the wherewithal either to open a book on Homeopathy and learn what it is all about or else go to the nearest search engine, look up some research, including double blinded placebo controlled research, and find out what it is all about. It so happens that it was a Homeopathy skeptic, pharmaceutical researcher M. Ennis, who had originally set out to disprove the water memory theory but instead was stunned to discover that her high dilution solution, in which all molecules of the stimulant had been diluted away, was STILL able to cause a biological reaction as though they were still there. This paper, published in Inflammation Research vol 53, p181, and the experiment itself which has been repeated many times with mostly positive results, goes unanswered, and studiously ignored by the water memory deniers who will resort to ANY rationalization - magic, placebo effect, or gamma rays from man in the moon marigolds, in order to avoid admitting that their 50 year old mental models of how molecules work, complete with little styrene plastic balls on sticks, is no longer adequate for modern science in the 21st century. ScepticsBane

Excellent article! (#8)
by Anonymous on Thu Jun 25, 2009 at 10:09:10 AM PDT
It is so nice, for once, to see things from a different perspective. Homeopathy has worked wonders for me when allopathic medicine failed me. Whenever I feel a virus coming, I visit the homeopath and the symptoms stop short a couple of hours after taking homeopathy whereas when I used to take pills and visit the doctor I was suffering for a whole week! Also, I had acne that was trated with antobiotics and suppressive creams. It was getting worse and worse each year, until I was 36 and still had pimples, lesions and scars. Then I found homeopathy. My skin improved greatly the first six months of treatment and a year later the acne had disappeared along with the unsightly scars. This versus 15 years of trials and failures with dermatologists! I am so thankful to homeopathy for what it has done for me (and what it has done for my children and husband). Great article, Michelle.


 POST A COMMENT

Your opinion matters! This is your chance to add to the story and voice your opinion. Links are welcome and encouraged.

We also encourage you to register an account and to login prior to posting comments. However, this is not required to post a comment. If you are not logged in, the comment will be posted as "Anonymous."

Subject:

Comment:

Enter the two words below to prove that you are a legitimate user.

 RELATED LINKS
> Also by Michelle Andujar
 USER INFO

Login to post comments

Need an Account? Signup

Username:
Password:
ADVERTISEMENT